There's plenty beyond Highlands but still nearby. Here are some of our favorites. Whole Foods is in the next town over, Middletown. We also love Trader Joe's in Shrewsbury and Middletown. Sea Bright is just south of Highlands and has an abundance of restaurants such as Tommy's Tavern + tap and Woody's Ocean Grille which also has a location in Tinton Falls. Also be sure to try Eventide Grille at Navesink Marina. Huddy's Inn is a great choice and a picturesque ride from The Beach House.